Broadway Pizza

Reviews

• Edward M.

  star star star star star 4 November 2026

  I love the pizza here.  New York style.  They deliver promptly.  A favorite place - a Tivoli landmark

• Joe H.

  star star star star star_border 3 November 2026

  I ordered the chicken parm here and it was very good. I usually get the calzones which are bigger then most and are very tasty as well! Place inside isn't very big for a sit down meal, so I would recommend take out only . Overall the food I've gotten is above average and it's pretty quick even on a Friday night ..

• Garrett M.

  star star star star star_border 3 November 2026

  Broadway is like Old Faithful...you know what you're getting and, while it won't blow your mind away, it definitely will leave you feeling satisfied. They typically have a good variety of slices to grab in the shop, from stuffed crust pepperoni to buffalo chicken to veggie lovers. It's not my favorite pizza in the area, but it's solid. What sets it apart is that if I don't feel like leaving home, someone will bring it to me...the only local spot that delivers.

• Chris B.

  star star star star_border star_border 21 October 2026

  When we were in desperate need of other sources of food for lunch today, we thought we'd pop in and eat.  Although my last review was left when my father came back from picking up pizza's from an "take out" we actually "ate in" today.  What a pleasant surprise we got.  It's amazing what you don't see when someone reports back their findings.
  
  Although the floor tiles are chipped in several spots, there is a big empty space for which people can move around in(he could place at least 1-2 more 2-person booths in this area).  There are several soda coolers on premise that contain an adequate amount of soda.
  
  This place doesn't appear to get much business.  You'd think that for a Saturday at 12:30 (noon) that they'd have a few more people than just us.  It seemed like no one else existed.  I mean, the pizza was very flaky and tender which got a bit harder once you reached the top (which is just the way a pizza crust is supposed to be), but hearing the guy (apparently the owner) make these pizzas on premises, means this guy puts his heart and sole into doing the best he can do with his business.
  
  I'm not a Tivoli resident, but if I'd be around and in need of any pizzas, I'd surely go back.

• James S.

  star star star star star 18 October 2026

  Been eating here for over a decade. Can't think of a time when I've had a bad slice. Delicious and friendly!